Limited or umbrella company - income comparison

Independent Contractor Services
Free IR35 & Contractor Tax Review
Call free 0844 259 0025 | Email

Limited or umbrella company - income comparison

Posted Jul 15, 2009

One of the biggest decisions you will make when starting up as a contractor is whether to trade via a limited company, or an umbrella company.

Choosing your business structure

The choice you make will depend on a number of factors, including:

1) Do you want to set up and run your own business?
2) Do you want control over all your financial affairs?
3) Do you want to maximise your post-tax income?
4) Do you fall under the IR35 rules?
5) Are you a short-term contractor?

For most contractors, the level of post-tax income is one of the most important factors to bear in mind when choosing which business structure to trade under.

Limited or Umbrella Calculator

Phil Richards from BFCA Limited Chartered Accountants has kindly provided Contract Eye readers with a downloadable Excel spreadsheet, which shows you what your post-tax income will be depending on which business structure you choose (limited company, umbrella company, or PAYE direct with an agency.)

You enter all your business expenses and overheads, your income, whether or not you are caught by IR35, and the spreadsheet will calculate your tax liability depending on which business structure you choose.

In some cases, there is a considerable difference between the levels of taxation between business structures, so this tool should help you make an informed choice as to whether you join an umbrella scheme, or set up your own company.

It is worth saying that post-tax income levels are a very important, but not always decisive factor in choosing a business structure. We recommend you also read the non-financial factors in our limited or umbrella company guide.

Download the Spreadsheet

To download the .xls spreadsheet (579Kb), simply click here. A very accessible user guide is contained within the document.

You can also view a 4 minute video tutorial on how to complete the spreadsheet via YouTube.

Thanks to BFCA Limited Chartered Accountants for use of the spreadsheet.

All content ©Contract Eye Ltd. Protected by Copyscape. Please scroll down for related articles.

Contractor Services

Professional Indemnity Insurance - Essential cover from Hiscox
The fair umbrella company - take home more pay with paraplus
InTouch Contractor Accounting - specialist online service & great advice
Parasol - the UK's favourite umbrella company
Contract Experts - ClearSky Accounting on 08000 325 326
Helix Management Ltd - Up to 90% retention. Same day payments.
Umbrella Company - 12,000 contractors can't be wrong!
Together we're stronger! - Join PCG, representing contractors
Cloud 9 Group - Umbrella Solutions only £27.50 per week
Qdos - IR35 experts - Providers of low cost contractor insurance
K & B Accountancy Group - Fixed fee contractor accounting only £75pm
Free IR35 & Tax Review - Call ICS on 0800 195 3750
Contractor Mortgages - the best deals, based on your contract rate alone!

Contractors set to pay more tax when dissolving a company, as ESC C16 changes are enacted
Changes to the ESC C16 rules have now been enacted by the Commons, meaning that contractors closing their limited companies will have to pay more tax when making a final distribution from 1st March 2012.

Dividends - how often should I take them, and when are they actually taxed?
We explore two of the questions most often asked by limited company contractors - involving the timing, and tax point of dividend declarations.

Self assessment on limited company dividend income
A contractor recently sent in an question asking whether or not his wife needs to register to fill in a tax return, even though no tax will be payable on her dividend income.

Limited company shareholders - changes to ESC C16 rules from March 2012
HMRC has announced that changes are to be made to the tax treatment of shareholder distributions when a limited company is wound up.

How much should limited company contractors set aside for income tax?
If you are a limited company director, how much money should you put aside to settle your personal tax bill each year?

Common sense self assessment tips for contractors
Some useful personal tax return tips for contractors to ensure you complete your self assessment form accurately and on time.

Can you reclaim the cost of home broadband from your limited company?
In the latest of our series on limited company expenses, we look at tax treatment of broadband installed at home.

Christmas party expenses guidelines for contractors
Although most contractors work as one or two-man limited companies, with no other employees, you are allowed to claim back the costs of an annual party for your staff, as long as you follow the HMRC guidelines carefully.

Can I buy health insurance or gym membership via my limited company
What are the tax implications of paying for health insurance or gym membership via your limited company?

Key accounting dates for limited company contractors
Some of the key accounting dates for limited company contractors, including PAYE/NIC and self assessment deadlines.

Tax guide for limited company contractors
When you start to contract via your own company, you will be liable for a number of business taxes, in addition to the individual taxes you will already be familiar with when you had a permanent job.

What is the Flat Rate VAT Scheme? An overview for IT contractors
An overview of the Flat Rate VAT Scheme, and how it could be advantageous for some limited company contractors.

New HMRC self assessment tax return penalties revealed
HMRC has introduced a new range of penalties for late tax return submissions and payments.

Limited company dividends - how much tax to pay?
If you are a limited company shareholder, how do you calculate the personal tax payable on dividends you receive?

BN66 - an overview of the offshore tax avoidance rules
In March 2008, the Chancellor announced a crackdown on the 'abuse' of loopholes in the double taxation treaties which exist between the UK and other countries. An overview of BN66 in light of the recent Huitson/Montpelier High Court case.