IR35 Guides - Are you inside or outside IR35?

Contractor Tax Protection
Tax Liability Cover (TLC35) and
IR35 insurance from Qdos Consulting

IR35 Forum - HMRC proposals to target higher risk IR35 targets

Posted Nov 23, 2011

The latest IR35 Forum minutes, from 9th November 2011, have been published on the HMRC site.

The Forum was set up to help oversee improvements in the way IR35 is currently administered, and is attended by experts from various industry bodies, as well as HMRC representatives.

Although there are few headline grabbing points contained the minutes of the fourth Forum get together since its creation following Budget 2011, some progress has been made, particularly on new IR35 risk profiling measures.

HMRC plans to focus on 'high risk' IR35 cases

One of the main discussions revolved around the current risk strategy employed to identify potential IR35 cases.

In a presentation, HMRC said that it intends to wants to increase its compliance activity against 'higher risk cases', and to amend its risk rules to "consider the overall nature of an intermediary, rather than narrowly at isolated contracts."

In order to help contractors (and others) work out if they are considered 'low' or 'high' risk, HMRC has proposed that it publishes its general risk criteria.

Other attendees welcomed the proposal, but some suggested that published risk criteria may not be sufficient to provide contractors with piece of mind that they wouldn't be considered 'high risk'.

HMRC said that the published criteria, together with improved general guidance, would "enable the majority of those providing their services through intermediaries to judge their level of risk."

Ultimately, focusing on higher risk cases can only be a good thing for the industry as a whole, although some cases will inevitably have to be referred to the Tribunals.

Other points from the meeting

  • In a presentation to the Forum, the PCG said they wanted to propose a tiered test approach where the indicators of business dictate the level of HMRC intervention.

  • Both PCG and HMRC proposals for future IR35 enforcement do seem to be reaching some areas of parity, especially over focusing on the nature of the business an individual is involved in first, before involving case law.

  • It was suggested that HMRC could take into account whether or not a business had taken specialist tax advice over IR35, when identifying risk.

  • Current proposals are for HMRC to introduce the new risk profiling and process from April 2012.

  • The next meeting is due to take place on 18th January 2012.

You can read the minutes in full, and past IR35 Forum minutes on the HMRC site

All content ©Contract Eye Ltd. Protected by Copyscape. Please scroll down for related articles.

Contractor Services


Related Articles

How the HMRC IR35 investigation process works
In light of the new HMRC IR35 guidance, we look at how an IR35 enquiry will typically originate - typically via an Employer Compliance Review.

New HMRC specialist teams set to increase number of IR35 reviews
Although the release of new HMRC guidance has made no difference to the underlying IR35 legislation itself, it could signal the start of a concerted effort by the tax authorities to carry out an increased number of compliance reviews.

New IR35 business test and IR35 scenarios go live
After weeks of speculation, HMRC has published new IR35 guidance, including a business entity test and a set of typical IR35 scenarios.

IR35 compliance - are you inside or outside IR35?
If HMRC decide to conduct an IR35 status enquiry, there are a number of factors which will be taken into account when determining whether or not your contract will fall within the scope of IR35 or not.

HMRC business test only a minor change to IR35 administration
Since the details of the proposed HMRC IR35 business test were first posted online last week, some have expressed 'shock' at these so-called leaks, but one must not forget that the official test itself is just a minor development in the process to overhaul IR35.

Most contractors would fail the IR35 business test
As the contents of the proposed IR35 business test appear online, it is easy to see why a rift has formed between HMRC and business groups, as it would appear that most contractors would face at least a medium risk of an IR35 investigation.

IR35 - Confirmation of Arrangements
Alongside a IR35 compliant contract, and matching working practices, a document confirming the true working arrangement between contractor and client is an important tool in demonstrating self employment. Includes free template download.

Over 3000 PCG members take IR35 business test trial
Over 3,000 PCG members have already taken part in a trial to determine how accurate the proposed HMRC IR35 business entity tests may be in real world scenarios.

Doubts raised over proposed IR35 business test
Concerns over the way IR35 is administered in the future have been raised as members of the IR35 Forum disagree with HMRC over the content and scoring of the proposed IR35 business test.

HMRC IR35 business test could go live in April 2012
The latest IR35 Forum minutes show that new trial business tests will be made live on the HMRC website in April, together with a set of typical scenarios to help establish how likely a business is to be caught by IR35.

Ambiguous IR35 Budget statement causes industry excitement
The final part of the short Budget 2012 statement afforded to IR35 has created further uncertainty for contractors, according to some industry experts.

IR35 remains firmly in place following Budget 2012
As was widely expected, the IR35 rules remain in place following Budget 2012, taking up only a few lines in the accompanying Budget documents.

Final OTS report suggests IR35 changes will be announced in April 2012
The Office of Tax Simplification has delivered its final report on HMRC administration, in time for the next Budget. The report reiterates the need for substantive progress to be made on IR35, with changes due to be announced in April 2012.

HMRC finalising strategy to overhaul IR35
HMRC is finalising its plans to improve the way IR35 is run, following input from a wide spectrum of industry experts via the IR35 Forum.

Would student loan boss have been caught by IR35?
Following news that the Student Loans Company boss has been receiving remuneration via his own personal services company, we ask whether this would this have made him a classic target for an IR35 investigation.

More IR35 Updates

Contractor Financials

ESSENTIAL IR35 GUIDES