IoD calls income shifting legislation technically defective

Published on Jan 23, 2008 |

The Institute of Directors has become the latest organisation to cast doubt on the proposed "income shifting" legislation. The IoD's response outlines the many failings of the Government's proposals.

The IoD says that the Government is answering the wrong question. The basic issue is not who gets the income, but deep structural features of the tax system, in particular the way in which dividends are taxed. Addressing that issue would require unpacking the whole tax system, including the fact that dividends come out of profits which have already suffered corporation tax. When we take that into account, we can see that there is much less unfairness than the Government imagines.

The IoD also state that the income shifting proposal would require people running small businesses to decide whether profits were being shared out in an arm's-length way. The concept of arm's-length arrangements will simply make no sense to small businesses. Even if it did, they would have to keep lots of extra records and would still be unable to give definitive answers. Even sophisticated multinationals have huge arguments about whether goods and services are traded at arm's-length prices, and need to assemble vast collections of evidence.

Most damning of all - the business organisation says that the draft legislation is technically defective. There will be scope for avoidance, especially using partnerships, and it will not work where a partnership has fixed profit shares or a company's dividend is determined automatically. If the draft as it stands gets onto the statute book, we can expect a slew of court cases a few years down the line.

Richard Baron, Head of Taxation at the IoD said:

"The Government tried to tackle income shifting in the courts, but in the Arctic Systems case (Jones v Garnett); they went down five-nil in the House of Lords. Now they are trying legislation, but they have come up with something hopeless. It misunderstands the basic issue, it will require small businesses to answer impossible questions, and its meaning is contentious even before you start to apply it to the real world."

Contractor Services

Income Protection (PHI) and Contractor Mortgages - Specialist quotes
Free Umbrella Company - Save over £1400 p.a. on fees with Springboard
Contract Experts - ClearSky Accounting on 08000 325 326
Qdos - IR35 experts - Providers of low cost insurances
Parasol - the UK's favourite umbrella company
Free IR35 & Tax Review - Call ICS on 0800 195 3750
K & B Accountancy Group- Fixed fee accounting for contractors only £75pm
Cloud 9 Group - Umbrella Solutions only £19.95 per week
Umbrella4Contractors - Low fees, same day setup
Professional Indemnity Insurance - Contractor PI cover


Back to top
Search Contract Eye

 Our Partners
Parasol PAYE umbrella
Award winning service
Contractor Accountants
Full Service, Fixed Fee!
Free Umbrella Company
Save over £1400 p.a.
ClearSky Accounting
From £95 per month
Fixed Fee Accounting
Contractor Specialists
Umbrella4Contractors
Low fees, same day setup
Free IR35 / Tax Review
Call ICS - 0800 195 3750
Umbrella Co. Solutions
Only £19.95 per week
PRINCE2, MSP & M_o_R
Maven Training

 Contractor Insurance
Hiscox Office Insurance
Instant Online Quote
IR35 Insurance
Essential Protection
Income Protection
If you're unable to work



 Contractor Services
Compare Insurance Deals
PI & Business Liability
Contractor Ltd Company
Instant online formation
IT Contractor Pensions
The last great tax break
Private Medical Insurance
Tailored contractor cover
IT Contractor Mortgages
Based on hourly rates!
Protect Your Income
Get a PHI quote
IT Contractor Life Cover
Protect your dependants
Critical Illness Cover
Comprehensive cover



 IT Contractor Guides
Contractor Umbrella
Umbrella Co. Advice
Contractor Accountant
Accountancy Directory
Contractor Rates
Latest rate news
IR35 Factors
Are you caught by IR35?
Corporation Tax
IT Contractor Guide
IT Contractor Mortgages
Get a mortgage quote
Contractor Insurance
Guide to contractor cover
IR35 Contract
Contract review guide
Contractor Life Cover
Contractor protection
IR35 Insurance
Tax investigation cover
Contractor PI Insurance
IT contractor cover
Umbrella Companies
Links to key providers
What is IR35?
Guide to the tax rules
IR35 Compliance
Is your contract caught?
Critical Illness Cover
Guide for contractors
Security Clearance
How do you get it?

Stay up to date with our RSS feed | Terms of Use | About Us | Directory | Site Map | MSC Legislation | Income Shifting

Copyright © 2006-9, Contract Eye Limited, All Rights Reserved.

UK Contractor Guides, Contractor Accountants, Umbrella Companies, IR35, Insurance, Contractor Mortgages
Design by Blue Egg Web Agency