How to become an IT Contractor - Becoming an IT Contractor

Best advice from Parasol Group
Over 47,000 satisfied contractors.
Umbrella or Ltd? We can help. Call 0800 458 0818.

Limited company sub-contractor deemed to be 'employee' in unfair dismissal claim

Posted Jul 1, 2009

Please note that the case detailed in this article was subsequently referred to the EAT in November 2009, with the original decision being reversed. Tilson was subsequently found to be an independent contractor after all.

A recent Employment Tribunal has found in favour of a limited company sub-contractor, who successfully managed to claim for unfair dismissal against his client as his working practices were seen to be akin to those of an 'employee'.

Andrew Tilson, a sub-contractor, working through his own limited company, took Alstom Transport to an employment tribunal - claiming for unfair dismissal.

Alstom, which operates several underground train services in the capital, claimed that Tilson could not claim for unfair dismissal as he was working via his own limited company, and was not an employee.

However, Tilson's barrister argued that, despite paying his own income tax and NICs, the way the claimant interacted with Alstom at the Golders Green depot was the true indicator of his employment status.

The Tribunal Judge agreed, and said that the close working relationship between the claimant and Alstom Transport demonstrated that Tilson was, in fact, an "employee", and could therefore claim for unfair dismissal under the terms of the Employment Rights Act 1996.

This hearing could have have ramifications for users of sub-contractors in many other industries apart from IT, and is more evidence that the true employment status of contractors can only be derived from the true working practices they follow, rather than the wording of any contracts they have in place, or the company structure they work under.

You can read Phil Richards' analysis of what this case means for contractors here.

All content ©Contract Eye Ltd. Protected by Copyscape. Please scroll down for related articles.

Contractor Services


Related Articles

HMRC business record checking programme suspended
HMRC much-criticised business record checking campaign has been postponed, pending changes to make the checks more targeted and 'educational'.

Contractors should benefit as web economy set to double by 2016
A landmark report from the Boston Consulting Group outlines how the digital economy is set to boom over the next five years, providing ample opportunities for contractors.

David Miliband accused of hipocrisy following income shifting revelations
The Daily Mail has revealed that the former foreign secretary has been channeling his lucrative post-Westminster earnings through a limited company, where the shares are split equally between himself and his wife.

Compliance and security key to ongoing success of Parasol
Parasol Group has announced strong results over the past year, and says the firm's commitment to compliance is a key factor in its ongoing success.

Temporary workplace expense schemes under scrutiny after HMRC wins major tax case against Reed
A landmark tax tribunal case has found a leading employment agency to be liable for substantial back taxes, after 500,000 temps were reimbursed for expenses, which should have been paid as salary.

Self employed numbers reach record high, but FCSA calls on Government to support flexible working
The latest UK employment figures show that although the unemployment rate now stands at 8.4%, the number of 'self employed' has reached a new high of 4.2m.

Clients urged to take more care preparing specs, as most IT projects deemed 'unsuccessful'
A software firm has urged the UK's businesses to take more care when providing specs for IT work, to avoid going over budget, or even having to shelve projects entirely.

Time running out to register for self assessment online
HMRC has reminded taxpayers new to self assessment that they only have a few days left to register for online submission.

Leading outsourcing site reports rapid growth in demand for IT freelancers
Statistics released by the world's leading outsourcing site, show that the demand for IT freelancers is growing strongly.

2011 - a busy year for the contracting industry
2011 has not been lacking in excitement, with the birth of the AWR, ongoing economic uncertainty, and confirmation that IR35 is here to stay.

Dan Pink describes an intensification of freelance working in the UK
In the headline freelance webinar for National Freelancers Day 2011, he describes the intensification of freelance working in both the UK and the US, and explores the changing relationship between individuals and organisations.

Contractors could benefit from infrastructure boost in gloomy Autumn Statement
The Chancellor's Autumn Statement will probably go down in history as one of the most depressing public finance statements ever made, although some of the measures may have a positive knock-on effect for contractors in the coming years.

What's the best advice you would give a new contractor?
A recent survey found that the most important thing a contractor would give to someone starting out is to make sure they have funds put aside for a rainy day.

Number of medical contractors surges, due to health industry shake-up
The number of doctors and nurses working as contractors has increased significantly over the past two years, according to a new study.

PM praises economic contribition made by freelancers
David Cameron has praised freelancers for the contribution they make the UK economy, as new figures reveal that there has been a 12% increase in freelancer numbers since 2008.

Qdosconsulting

Looking for a new service provider?

Accountants
Umbrella Companies

More Contracting News